Gao Zi II · 孟子 6B.5

Passage 05

mèngzōurènwéirènchǔshǒujiāoshòuzhīérbàochǔpíngchǔwéixiāngjiāoshòuzhīérbàoyóuzōuzhīrènjiànyóupíngzhījiànchǔyuēliánjiànwènyuēzhīrènjiànzhījiànchǔwéiwéixiāngyuēfēishūyuēxiǎngduōyuēxiǎngwéizhìxiǎngwéichéngxiǎngyuèhuòwènzhīyuēzhīzōuchǔzhīpíng

When Mencius was residing in Zou, the younger brother of the chief of Ren, who was guardian of Ren at the time, paid his respects to him by a present of silks, which Mencius received, not going to acknowledge it. When he was sojourning in Ping Lu, Chu, who was prime minister of the State, sent him a similar present, which he received in the same way. Subsequently, going from Zou to Ren, he visited the guardian; but when he went from Ping Lu to the capital of Qi, he did not visit the minister Chu. The disciple Wu Lu was glad, and said, 'I have got an opportunity to obtain some instruction.' He asked accordingly, 'Master, when you went to Ren, you visited the chief's brother; and when you went to Qi, you did not visit Chu. Was it not because he is only the minister?' Mencius replied, 'No. It is said in the Book of History, "In presenting an offering to a superior, most depends on the demonstrations of respect. If those demonstrations are not equal to the things offeredred, we say there is no offering, that is, there is no act of the will presenting the offering." This is because the things so offered do not constitute an offering to a superior.' Wu Lu was pleased, and when some one asked him what Mencius meant, he said, 'The younger of Ren could not go to Zou, but the minister Chu might have gone to Ping Lu.'

First-principles reading

Begin with the words and context, expose the premise beneath the argument, then test the conditions and limits of the principle.