Teng Wen Gong I · 孟子 3A.2

Passage 02

téngdìnggōnghōngshìwèirányǒuyuēzhěmèngchángyánsòngxīnzhōngwàngjīnxìngzhì使shǐwènmèngránhòuxíngshìrányǒuzhīzōuwènmèngmèngyuēshànqīnsāngsuǒjìncéngyuēshēngshìzhīzàngzhīzhīwèixiàozhūhóuzhīwèizhīxuésuīránchángwénzhīsānniánzhīsāngzhāishūzhīzhānzhōuzhīshítiānshùrénsāndàigòngzhīrányǒufǎnmìngdìngwéisānniánzhīsāngxiōngbǎiguānjiēyuēzōngguóxiānjūnzhīxíngxiānjūnzhīxíngzhìzhīshēnérfǎnzhīqiězhìyuēsāngcóngxiānyuēyǒusuǒshòuzhīwèirányǒuyuēwèichángxuéwènhǎochíshìjiànjīnxiōngbǎiguānkǒngnéngjìnshìwéiwènmèngrányǒuzhīzōuwènmèngmèngyuēránqiúzhěkǒngyuējūnhōngtīngzhǒngzǎizhānzhōumiànshēnwèiérbǎiguānyǒugǎnāixiānzhīshàngyǒuhǎozhěxiàyǒushènyānzhějūnzhīfēngxiǎorénzhīcǎocǎoshàngzhīfēngyǎnshìzàishìrányǒufǎnmìngshìyuēránshìchéngzàiyuèwèiyǒumìngjièbǎiguānrénwèiyuēzhīzhìzàngfāngláiguānzhīyánzhīzhīāidiàozhěyuè

When the duke Ding of Teng died, the prince said to Ran You, 'Formerly, Mencius spoke with me in Song, and in my mind I have never forgotten his words. Now, alas! this great duty to my father devolves upon me; I wish to send you to ask the advice of Mencius, and then to proceed to its various services' Ran You accordingly proceeded to Zou, and consulted Mencius. Mencius said, 'Is this not good? In discharging the funeral duties to parents, men indeed feel constrained to do their utmost. The philosopher Zeng said, "When parents are alive, they should be served according to propriety; when they are dead, they should be buried according to propriety; and they should be sacrificed to according to propriety - this may be called filial piety." The ceremonies to be observed by the princes I have not learned, but I have heard these points: that the three years' mourning, the garment of coarse cloth with its lower edge even, and the eating of congee, were equally prescribed by the three dynasties, and binding on all, from the sovereign to the mass of the people.' Ran You reported the execution of his commission, and the prince determined that the three years' mourning should be observed. His aged relatives, and the body of the officers, did not wish that it should be so, and said, 'The former princes of Lu, that kingdom which we honour, have, none of them, observed this practice, neither have any of our own former princes observed it. For you to act contrary to their example is not proper. Moreover, the History says, "In the observances of mourning and sacrifice, ancestors are to be followed," meaning that they received those things from a proper source to hand them down.' The prince said again to Ran You, 'Hitherto, I have not given myself to the pursuit of learning, but have found my pleasure in horsemanship and sword-exercise, and now I don't come up to the wishes of my aged relatives and the officers. I am afraid I may not be able to discharge my duty in the great business that I have entered on; do you again consult Mencius for me.' On this, Ran You went again to Zou, and consulted Mencius. Mencius said, 'It is so, but he may not seek a remedy in others, but only in himself. Confucius said, "When a prince dies, his successor entrusts the administration to the prime minister. He sips the congee. His face is of a deep black. He approaches the place of mourning, and weeps. Of all the officers and inferior ministers there is not one who will presume not to join in the lamentation, he setting them this example. What the superior loves, his inferiors will be found to love exceedingly. The relation between superiors and inferiors is like that between the wind and grass. The grass must bend when the wind blows upon it." The business depends on the prince.' Ran You returned with this answer to his commission, and the prince said, 'It is so. The matter does indeed depend on me.' So for five months he dwelt in the shed, without issuing an order or a caution. All the officers and his relatives said, 'He may be said to understand the ceremonies.' When the time of interment arrived, they came from all quarters of the State to witness it. Those who had come from other States to condole with him, were greatly pleased with the deep dejection of his countenance and the mournfulness of his wailing and weeping.

First-principles reading

Begin with the words and context, expose the premise beneath the argument, then test the conditions and limits of the principle.