Wan Zhang II · 孟子 5B.2

Passage 02

běijīngwènyuēzhōushìbānjué祿zhīmèngyuēxiángwénzhūhóuèhàiérjiēránérchángwénlüètiānwèigōngwèihóuwèiwèinántóngwèifánděngjūnwèiqīngwèidàifuwèishàngshìwèizhōngshìwèixiàshìwèifánliùděngtiānzhīzhìfāngqiāngōnghóujiēfāngbǎishínánshífánděngnéngshítiānzhūhóuyuēyōngtiānzhīqīngshòushìhóudàifushòushìyuánshìshòushìnánguófāngbǎijūnshíqīng祿qīng祿dàifudàifubèishàngshìshàngshìbèizhōngshìzhōngshìbèixiàshìxiàshìshùrénzàiguānzhětóng祿祿dàigēngguófāngshíjūnshíqīng祿qīng祿sāndàifudàifubèishàngshìshàngshìbèizhōngshìzhōngshìbèixiàshìxiàshìshùrénzàiguānzhětóng祿祿dàigēngxiǎoguófāngshíjūnshíqīng祿qīng祿èrdàifubèishàngshìshàngshìbèizhōngshìzhōngshìbèixiàshìxiàshìshùrénzàiguānzhětóng祿祿dàigēnggēngzhězhīsuǒhuòbǎibǎizhīfènshàngnóngshíjiǔrénshàngshírénzhōngshírénzhōngshíliùrénxiàshírénshùrénzàiguānzhě祿shìwéichà

Bei Gong Qi asked Mencius, saying, 'What was the arrangement of dignities and emoluments determined by the House of Zhou?' Mencius replied, 'The particulars of that arrangement cannot be learned, for the princes, disliking them as injurious to themselves, have all made away with the records of them. Still I have learned the general outline of them. The Son of Heaven constituted one dignity; the Gong one; the Hou one; the Bai one; and the Zi and the Nan each one of equal rank - altogether making five degrees of rank. The Ruler again constituted one dignity; the Chief Minister one; the Great Officers one; the Scholars of the First Class one; those of the Middle Class one; and those of the Lowest Class one - altogether making six degrees of dignity. 'To the Son of Heaven there was allotted a territory of a thousand li square. A Gong and a Hou had each a hundred li square. A Bai had seventy li, and a Zi and a Nan had each fifty li. The assignments altogether were of four amounts. Where the territory did not amount to fifty li, the chief could not have access himself to the Son of Heaven. His land was attached to some Hou-ship, and was called a Fu Yong. The Chief ministers of the Son of Heaven received an amount of territory equal to that of a Hou; a Great officer received as much as a Bai; and a scholar of the first class as much as a Zi or a Nan. 'In a great State, where the territory was a hundred li square, the ruler had ten times as much income as his Chief ministers; a Chief minister four times as much as a Great officer; a Great officer twice as much as a scholar of the first class; a scholar of the first class twice as much as one of the middle; a scholar of the middle class twice as much as one of the lowest; the scholars of the lowest class, and such of the common people as were employed about the government offices, had for their emolument as much as was equal to what they would have made by tilling the fields. In a State of the next order, where the territory was seventy li square, the ruler had ten times as much revenue as his Chief minister; a Chief minister three times as much as a Great officer; a Great officer twice as much as a scholar of the first class; a scholar of the first class twice as much as one of the middle; a scholar of the middle class twice as much as one of the lowest; the scholars of the lowest class, and such of the common people as were employed about the government offices, had for their emolument as much as was equal to what they would have made by tilling the fields. In a small State, where the territory was fifty li square, the ruler had ten times as much revenue as his Chief minister; a Chief minister had twice as much as a Great officer; a Great officer twice as much as a scholar of the highest class; a scholar of the highest class twice as much as one of the middle; a scholar of the middle class twice as much as one of the lowest; scholars of the lowest class, and such of the common people as were employed about the government offices, had the same emolument - as much, namely, as was equal to what they would have made by tilling the fields. As to those who tilled the fields, each husbandman received a hundred mu. When those mu were manured, the best husbandmen of the highest class supported nine individuals, and those ranking next to them supported eight. The best husbandmen of the second class supported seven individuals, and those ranking next to them supported six; while husbandmen of the lowest class only supported five. The salaries of the common people who were employed about the government offices were regulated according to these differences.'

First-principles reading

Begin with the words and context, expose the premise beneath the argument, then test the conditions and limits of the principle.