Jin Xin I · 孟子 7A.31

Passage 31

gōngsūnchǒuyuēyǐnyuēxiáshùnfàngtàijiǎtóngmínyuètàijiǎxiányòufǎnzhīmínyuèxiánzhězhīwéirénchénjūnxiánfàngmèngyuēyǒuyǐnzhīzhìyǐnzhīzhìcuàn

Gong Sun Chou said, 'Yi Yin said, "I cannot be near and see him so disobedient to reason," and therewith he banished Tai Jia to Tong. The people were much pleased. When Tai Jia became virtuous, he brought him back, and the people were again much pleased. When worthies are ministers, may they indeed banish their sovereigns in this way when they are not virtuous?' Mencius replied, 'If they have the same purpose as Yi Yin, they may. If they have not the same purpose, it would be usurpation.'

First-principles reading

Begin with the words and context, expose the premise beneath the argument, then test the conditions and limits of the principle.